Yesssss! College football is here. I love saturdays. I was one of those communist (that’s what my coach called all soccer players) kickers at Pitt. I never got off the bench and still plucking the splinters out, but saturdays were religious. Anything can happen. For the most part, what you get is 18-22 year olds laying it out there on every play. The first weekend of play normally has games like Pitt vs E. Michigan, Florida vs W. Kentucky, USC vs St Mary’s School for the Blind, and Michigan vs. Appalachian St, and the scores typically resemble a Team USA basketball game vs Guatemala (Cue the music - “Which one of these is not like the others?”). Just in case you were on a remote island somewhere, living under a rock or work in a nuclear missile silo, the Mountaineers of Boooooooone, NC (yes, I’ve been there. great college town), pulled the week 1 shocker. Do you think ASU will have some trouble scheduling that “scrimmage game” next year? The news was reporting that after the game, students from App. State went to their own field (please note the game was in Michigan) and tore down the goal posts! That’s crazy! I can honestly say I have never heard of that happening.
Just in case some of you don’t know how this works, top shelf Division 1 teams normally schedule a Div 1-AA or a weak Div 1 teams to open the season - one last chance to work out the kinks, actually hit someone that isn’t a teammate, look impressive to the alumni, and add a “W” to the overall record. On top of that, these weak teams normally get payments in the 6-figures for the appearance (most of which goes to medical bills). Rumor has it, ASU got a cool $400k. At this point, do you think Michigan is looking for a refund? Not too may teams go into Ann Arbor and walk out with a win, let alone the game U of M put on the schedule as the home opener.
Now, let’s give Appalachian some credit. They are not a pushover. For the past decade or so, they have played and sometimes won at the top teams in the ACC as their season opener. Teams like Wake Forest and NC State - who no longer want to play them. While ASU has been doing this, they consistently are ranked in the top-10 of Div 1-AA, giving the Div 1-A teams a run, and oh, lets not forget most recently back-to-back national titles from the division formally known as 1-AA. So, anyone, thinking that ASU is a guaranteed “W” needs to have their head examined. Congrats Lloyd Carr, you now have the wrath of “Big Blue” Nation calling for your job.
This brings me one small thing that college football needs to fix until we get a playoff. Rankings. I believe pre-season rankings are fine, something that sells magazines and gets alumni fired up. But here’s where the problem comes in - any team that starts too far down in rankings at the beginning of the year has no shot at either a national title or a BCS bowl. Why not start ranking the teams after we get a chance to see them play - lets say 4 games? The rankings now are based on what, last years team, reputation, returning starters and schedule? How can you reasonably predict a top 25 without seeing them play a single game? I give you Exhibit A - the 2007 version of University of Michigan at #5 (I’m predicting they will fall completely out of the poll). What does that make ASU?
Congrats Appalachian (and especially my brother Pete and his wife kelly, who are both ASU grads)! Live in the moment. I’m sure there were lots of hangovers on sunday, and monday…